Dalai Lama says Tibet is a Chinese domestic issue
Dalai lama persecution
The Dalai Lama suppresses democracy and freedom of expression
As the unelected political and spiritual leader of the Tibetan people, the Dalai Lama’s influence over his government, executive and people is all-pervasive. Because of the exalted position he enjoys his decisions are beyond reproach or even serious debate.
So powerful is this control that almost no Tibetan will dare criticise the Dalai Lama’s activities for fear of the swift retribution that they know would follow. Nowhere is this seen more clearly than in the repression of freedom of speech in the Tibetan exile community.
"Concerning democratisation I can only say that the exile government is half-hearted, even embarrassingly so. The question of independence was taken by the executive alone. Not even the exile parliament was asked, let alone the people. I say: the decision to give up the goal of independence is undemocratic. "
Panorama, German Documentary, 20 November 1997
Lhasang Tsering
In his statement at a panel discussion in Dharamshala on June 21, Rimpoche admitted that the Kalon Tripa did not have the freedom to operate in the usual manner but had to work within a framework where ... the Dalai Lama’s wishes were absolutely and unquestionably predominant. In response to a question from the audience about the priorities of the Prime Ministers duties, Rimpoche responded, very clearly, that it was important for the kalon tripa “to even anticipate the Dalai Lama’s unstated thoughts and direct his efforts to their realization.”
... the role of the kalon tripa in the exile Tibetan government is not that of a prime minister in a democratic nation as India or the UK (who actually initiates and formulates national policy) but rather that of a “first minister of the crown” in a pre-democratic monarchy or theocracy. The latter statement about anticipating His Holiness’s thoughts echoes the fawning of the grand eunuch in a decaying Oriental court, than the free and candid expression of a democratically elected leader....
Waiting for Mangtso
Jamyang Norbu
Not only is there no encouragement and support for a free Tibetan press, there is instead a near extinguishing of freedom of expression in Tibetan exile society … Samdong Rinpoche, the Speaker of the Tibetan Parliament in exile, … declared … that the Tibetan Parliament should find new ways to control the Tibetan press.
Tibetan News, Autumn 1997
Jamyang Norbu
A considerable number of new books written in Tibetan ... have been censored or banned from publication [by the Tibetan exile government] because they do not conform to the desired image of traditional Tibetan society. Any serious discussion of history and of possible shortcomings in the society before 1959 is taboo.
Resistence and Reform in Tibet
Heather Stoddard
The ban on books for the simple reason that the writers had expressed ideas that do not conform to the official line of thinking – be it on history or politics – has been among the biggest blots against our exile government.
in the Foreword to Jamyang Norbu's Illusion and Reality
Lhasang Tsering
Attacks (often physical and violent) were directed against Tibetan intellectuals who wrote anything that could be remotely construed as critical of the Dalai Lama, Buddhism or Gyalo Thondup.... His Holiness has, unfortunately, never once condemned these acts of violence and intimidation being carried out in his name.
Waiting for Mangtso
Jamyang Norbu
Since the Tibetan exile government in Dharamsala is not legitimately a government by legal and international standards, it is difficult to analyze this problematic [sic] in an easy or straightforward way. Democratic it is not. The Tibetan people have never been asked to vote on any of the major political decisions concerning the future of their country either inside or outside Tibet.
Often not even the Assembly and Cabinet (Kashag) are asked. Even more basic, freedom of speech, the very foundation of democratic striving, is woefully absent among exile Tibetans. Criticism of official exile government business is usually dismissed as being of Chinese origin.’
Condemned to Silence: A Tibetan Identity Crisis
Ursula Bernis
It is unfortunate but equally true that the Dalai Lama in exile has tended to discourage the emergence of alternative leaders, unless officially approved by him.
Tibet: The Road Ahead
Dawa Norbu
Dawa Norbu, Tibet: The Road Ahead (London: Rider, 1997).
Imagining Tibet, eds. Thierry Dodin & Heinz Räther, 301 (Boston: Wisdom Publications, 2001).
Ursula Bernis, Exiled from Exile 1996-1999.
A. Tom Grunfeld, The Making of Modern Tibet (New York & London: M.E. Sharpe 1996), 200-1.
Constitution of the Tibetan Government in Exile.
Fourteenth Dalai Lama, Freedom in Exile (Great Britain, Abacus edition, 2002), 233-4.
Beat Regli, Dalai Lama: Discord in Exile, 10 vor 10, (DRS Swiss Television), January 1998, Part 2.
Palden Gyal, Tibetan News, ‘Paper Tigers’, No. 22, Spring 1997.
Jamyang Norbu, Tibetan News, ‘Tibet’s Cultural Confusion’, No.21, Autumn 1997.
Heather Stoddard, ‘Tibetan Publications and National Identity’, Robbie Barnett and Shirin Akiner (eds.), Resistance and Reform in Tibet, 121-56 (London: Hurst and Co.)
Lhasang Tsering in Foreword to Illusion and Reality by Jamyang Norbu (Dharamsala: Tibetan Youth Congress, 1989), 10.
The Dalai Lama, Tibet Foundation Newsletter No. 22, ‘Meaningful Dialogue’, November 1997.
Tsering Wangyal, Tibetan Review Vol XIV No.9, September 1979.
Also see...
- The Dalai Lama is mixing religion and politics
- Reting Lama - How he chose the false Dalai Lama
- 21st Century Buddhist Dictator - The Dalai Lama
- Hypocrite Dalai Lama - Report from India
- The Dalai Lama supports Violence
- The Dalai Lama suppresses Freedom of Religion
- The Dalai Lama has murky finances
- The Dalai Lama relies on Spirits and Trance Oracles
- The Dalai Lama is politically and spiritually incompetent
- The Dalai Lama suppresses democracy and freedom of expression
- The Dalai Lama has close ties to the Nazis
- Torture and Execution Ordered by the Thirteenth Dalai Lama
- Prisoners of the Potala: The Sixth to Twelfth Dalai Lamas
- Wars and Murders ordered by the Fifth Dalai Lama
- The Pure Dharma of the Early Dalai Lamas
- The Dalai Lama has CIA connections
- The Dalai Lama is a communist
- What has the Dalai Lama achieved?
The Western Shugden Society has based its research on the works of respected and independent scholars, investigative journalists and on original source material to demonstrate its position. Some of this material is freely available on the internet. Wherever possible we have provided links to the original documents or means to access them. We invite you to investigate them for yourself.
The Undemocratic Dalai Lama
1:19
68 years as the unelected head of Tibetans. Isn’t that a dictatorship?
2:29
